Does decriminilisation of prostitution protect sex workers?
Introduction:
Sex,Stripping,Teasing,Flashing,Sex Tourism
It has been suggested that female poverty is the result of sexual discrimination and low wages in the labour market and that prostitution is a strategy for female survival under conditions of poverty
A prostitute is any person who earns a living by the indiscriminate, willing and emotionally indifferent provision of services against payment,usually in advance but not necessarily in cash.
Prostitution  in  the  context of  sex  tourism  has  been  labelled as  a  form of  sexual  imperialism  by sections  of the  Asian  women’s  movement who  point  to  the profits  made  by  tour operators  from  industrial countries  by incorporating  prostitutes’ services  in  their packages  of  services sold  to  male tourists. This is  attributed  to  the   inferior economic position of  some Asian  countries  which  sought to gain from  international  trade  through tourism. 
Another  view  is  that  sexuality  has  now  been  transformed  to  sexual labour  in  the  transition  to  capitalism. Female sexuality has become a commodity  as  a result of  changing perceptions  of  the  value  of  their  sexuality. As  new  forms of production  were introduced, the  value of  female  sexuality  has  changed  and  their sexuality  and labour have  become a  new  form of property forcing  them to  use it  for their survival. movement
There  has  been  attempts  to  relate  prostitution  to  marriage  where  women  are traded as  sexual   objects. Marriage  may  be  an  economic  transaction  where girls  or  women  are purchased  through a  bride price  or  a fee to an introduction agency.
Prostitution  has its origin and counterpart in traditional  forms  of  exchange of girls or women for cash, child marriage, temporary marriage   and trafficking of women  for marriage  .The  mail order   bride  industry has integrated the  sale of women  into the global  sex industry where women  are trapped  by poverty and lack of remedy such as  divorce .Here  marriage still  reflects an aspect of prostitution since women have to allow access to  their bodies in return for survival. For example, muta among  shia moslems  where  marriage even  for  a couple  of hours for  sex  is seen as religiously acceptable  is  an  example.
Sale  of  visual  sex    for  purely  economic  considerations  is not the same  as prostitution  but amounts  to  commercialisation  of  the  body.
Stripping, flashing  and teasing  for  a  living  may  be  analysed  at  various levels.Firstly, as predominantly sexual  .Here, the  performance  is  dominated  by  sexual  activity.Secondly,  as predominabtly  entertainment  by the  amount of  entertainment it  provides  by  way  of  dancing.A  third  variety  is   a combination  of  both.The  performances  include  baring of  breasts, flashing by  lowering the G-string  to expose  the  pubic  area, floor  work which  is  that segment  which is  done,sitting,kneeling  or  lying  on the  floor or prop work which may  include use  of  the  dance pole  on stage.
The  type   of  the  women  who   enter  stripping  tend  to narcissistic who  are  fully  aware  of   their  attractiveness.However,the  display  of  skin before  a  paying  audience  is  purely  for  economic  considerations  and not for   her own sexual  arousal.The   strippers basic   and  salable  product  is  visual  sex.The  music  and dancing used  in their  a performance  are  mere  accessories.The  occupational  conditions  means,firstly,isolation from  affective social relationships,secondly,unsatisfactory  relationships  with  males  and  thirdly   an  opportunity   structure  allowing  a  wide  range  of sexual  behaviour.
As  the  clubs seek to  maximize profits they  put on  many dancers which creates  greater competition  , forces down earnings and  compels the stripper  to  engage in practices such as lap dancing or prostitution.
The profit levels  are are  enhanced  by  the  non-payment of  benefits  such as sick benefits  since club owners treat strippers  as  independent contractors renting  space in the club.
Female  sex tourism  by western tourists   is  motivated by racist stereotypes using sex tourism to boost their privileged  race  and  class status  in  their  interaction  with  black   men in the Africa
or  the  Carribean.The  women  are  looking for black  men  with  good  bodies  or  firm and muscular machines  they  can control.
.
The  meaning  of  prostitution  in  the  United  Kingdom was  determined in law  by the decision of  the court of Appeal in Regina V McFarlane(1993) when it dismissed an appeal by a man convicted of living on the earnings of prostitution and determined that, in considering the mischief of harassment and nuisance to members of the public on the streets, the distinction between “a clipper” and “a hooker” was immaterial.
The unsuccessful appeal was brought by Eric McFarlane, aged 39, from his conviction at Knightsbridge Crown Court, before Judge Hordern, QC and a jury, on a  charge of  living wholly or in partly on the earnings of the prostitution of a woman, contrary to of the Sexual Offences Act 1956. He was sentenced to four months imprisonment.
Prostitutes  can  be divided,firstly,the  lower-class  hooker or streetwalker,,secondly,the call girl  and thirdly, the pleasure  girl.The  hooker does  not  have  a  fixed  address  ,relying  on passing trade. The  call girl is  more  expensive.Her services  are  more expensive  because  of  the cost   of  accommodation   and telephone are  included.She  can  afford  to  be  more selective in her choice  of  customers and services offered.The  pleasure-  girl includes models, beauty queens, social climbers  and cover girls.A term referring  to  all  women  using  their  bodies and  female attraction not  merely  in  exchange  for money  but  in pursuit of  getting contacts with  the famous  and powereful  and  to  achieve social advancement.
In  the  indoor  markets  where  the  quality  of  service  implies  that  a  hooker  may  stay  with   a   client  for  hours  rather  than  minutes, a  set  routine  may  emerge. Sandra, a call girl  describes  the  five  stage  process  she  goes  through with  each  client  as”settling  him  in”,” getting him  going”, getting  him  to  shoot  his load”,”reassuring  him”, “normalising”  and “getting  him out.”
The  prostitute  does  what  every  woman  continues  to  do-they  sell  their  bodies  for money  while  women  do  likewise  for  love; prostitute’s  tease  men  with  their provocative  mini skirts  while  women  do  the  same  fully dressed. Women have  developed  the  technique  of surviving  and  being  attractive  for  the sake of  her partner  and kids while  a prostitutes  does  the same for herself and her customers.
They  may be  divided  into  two  distinct groups.Firstly,those  who  do it  out  of  free  will (voluntary prostitutes) and  secondly,those  who  do it  because  of  their  own  psycho-neurotic needs(compulsive  prostitutes)There  may  be three  factors  that  influence  hers  decision  in  the case  of  the  second  group;namely,predisposing  ,attracting and precipitating factors. Predisposing  factors  may  be  promiscuous parents  or  a  broken home,attractive  factors  may  be  monetary gains  or  a  more  exciting life and precipitating factors may be  unhappy love life.
Those  who  require  the  services  of  prostitutes  may be  divided  into   various  categories.
Firstly,the  male  who for  one reason  or the other  is  deprived  of  sexual gratification.Examples  include  sailors, soldiers, commercial  travellers  police men  or the  widower  who  may  not  want  to  remarry.
Secondly, the  shy  young  man  who  is  unable  to   experiment  with  girls  of  his  own
age  group  because   he  is  unsure  of  himself. Thirdly, lonely men  who  need  company.
Fourthly,deviant  men  whose  sexual  needs   are  not  satisfied  by  normal  intercourse with  a  woman.
Fifthly,husbands  or partners  of  menopausal  women  who  are   less inclined  to  sexual
intercourse  than  they  were  a few years  back. For  women  between  the   ages of  45-55,the  menopause  is  a  difficult period in  terms  of  sexual  intercourse. Symptoms  of  the  menopause include   nervousness,headaches,instability,insomnia,poor memory,moodiness,feelings  of  inadequacy,tiredness,lack of  concentration,palpitations,back  ache  and  aching  joints,. The   loss  of oestrogen   causes   some  wasting away  of  the genital  tract resulting  in  potential irritation  and  discomfort  and  reduced  sensitivity  of  the  vaginal  walls and  greater  unresponsiveness  which in combination  with   the  forgoing factors   make a loss   of  libido   likely  and  even  when  even  intercourse  is  wanted  it  can either prove  to be less  satisfying  than usual  or less enjoyable  or  in  a   number  of caseseven quite  painful. 
Men  who  find  themselves  in  this  kind  of  situation  may  turn their   attention  to  to street  walkers  or  other  types  of  prostitutes.  
Reasons  given  by  clients   for accessing  the  services  of  hookers  include,” no  other  partner” “,not  enough  sex  with  wife/partner”, “excitement”  and  “  an  alternative   to  masturbation. According one  client,”  doing  it   myself  is  not  much  fun, “Estimates of the  numbers  of  clients based  on the numbers  of  hookers  and  the  amount  of  work  they  do indicates  that  11  per  cent  of  the  adult male  population in  the UK  pays  for  sex  fairly  regularly.
The  level  of resources  that  would  be  required  to  police   the behaviour of  such a large  proportion of the population is unthinkable.Police  and  allied  agencies who have  to monitor  and  arrest  violent  sex offenders  are  already  overstretched.
Opponents  of prostitution  argue that  it  is  not possible  to  raise  prostitution  to  the level  of a profession  because professions  such  as  law  and medicine  require  candidates  to  attain a  body  of  skills   and  attain  an  examinable  standard  assessed  by  their peers.Professional   bodies  play gatekeeping roles  to  ensure  that  attractive  opportunities opportunities open to professionals  are  not  undermined  by  cheaper  unqualified labour.
Consequently, licensing  of  prostitutes  would  only  be meaningful  if  they  are    able  to undertake  courses  to  equip  them  for  their  profession  while  licensing   boards  would
impose  standards  which  reflect  the  kinds  of  knowledge  and skills required  for  the  sex provider’s  work  and  protect  clients from  any  harm  resulting  from  her  work.
Other  supporters  of  prostitution  suggest  that  women possess special  sexual  skills.Street walkers  stress  the   skills of  getting  men to  ejaculate  rapidly   to  avoid  the  discomfort of  being  used  too long.Critics  of  this  line of  argument  state  that  this consists  of moving  round and  making  noises   which  does  not  seem  to  be  more specialised  than  the  action of  other women  who  are  not  getting paid  who  want  the  men  they live  with to  end dull sexual  intercourse  so  they  can  go to sleep.
Some of  the arguments  in  favour  of  decriminalization of  prostitution  include  reduction of teenage  pregnancies, elimination  traditional  hypocrisy and  double  standards, reduction of  crime  by  bringing  down  the  level of  blackmail,violence,pimps.Legalization  of brothels will  strengthen  the marriage  bond  and  reduce  the  number of  divorces.By  reducing  divorces,it  will contribute  to  strengthening  the shrinking  family  unit  and  thus  reduce
juvenile  crime.
Besides,it  has  been  suggested  that  prostitution  provides  a  useful  social  service  for the  sick,the  ugly,the  deformed,the old  and  the  disabled.For  example,sexual  frustration among  prisoners is  a  cause   of  homosexuality  among  inmates.This  argument  is  supported  by  the  fact  that   homosexuality  is  rampant  is  residential boys schools  where  access  to  the  opposite  sex  is  quite  restricted.
Further,it  is  argued   that  female  prostitution  tends to  reduce  homosexuality.
By  associating  with  females the  male learns the  traits  of  sensitivity, tenderness  and  warmth which  will  ultimately  make  him  a  successful partner.Where  masculine  traits  are
lacking the male  becomes  either  too  closely associated with  the  mother  or  finds  himself in a  position  of  conflict  with  her.His familiarity  with  persons  of  the  opposite  sex other  than  his mother  is   adversely  affected. This  may explain  why  some  men are  put  off  by  an  increasing  number  of strong-willed, assertive  group  of  women
who as  a  reaction  prefer  friendship  with other men.
Further,at  a  social  level  it  is  argued that  decriminalisation  will eradicate  
traditional hypocrisy  and make  double  standards  unnecessary  as well  as  reduce
crime  generally. For  example, street walkers  who  are  on  drugs  work  much longer
hours  than  those  who are not.Similarly,  those  who  have   to pay fines will  have
to  work  harder  than  those  who  are not caught.More  frequent contacts  are  more
likely  to result   in the spread  of  sexually  transmitted disease.It  likely  that
a  prostitute  who  operates  from a  licensed brothel would  not  need  the protection of the  kind provided  by pimps  or  criminal  organizations  or   need  to  work  long hours
and   hence  find  drug  use  unnecessary.
However,it  has  been  suggested  that  there  are  pimps   whose  services  prostitutes
consider  to  be  an  asset  by  acting  as  agents. They  offer  a  series  of  practical  services for a  price  which  is  necessary such as  soliciting  for  sex  by  finding  clients,giving  warnings of  police  arrivals  as  well  as protection  from  violence  or  robbery  or  giving  free  sex  services.
When  it  comes  to  present  day  society,there  appears  to  be  some  confusion  in its
approach  to  love  and marriage.Women  have  worsened  the situation by  maintaining
 a degree  of  universality  of her role  within marriage   and  society  by  claiming
that  they  can  be wife,mother,sister,mistress  and  friend  at the same time.Previously,there
was a distinction  between  profane   and sacred  love  and it  was  considered  acceptable  that  a   human  being  is  capable  of  both  of  looking  up to  heaven   and wallowing in hell.The  distinction between  pure  and  impure  love is  to  highlight  the  idea  that  our
sexuality  is  capable  of  being  directed  in  at least two ways.
Indeed,  there is  a   school of  thought  which  divides  women  into  three  categories
When  it  comes  availability  of  sexual  favours.Firstly,those  loyal  to  one man who  would  prefer  death  to ‘forced’ intercourse.Secondly,the   not  so  high  minded  who  would  occasionally   provide  sexual  favours  to  achieve an  objective  and thirdly,the saleswoman
who  because  of  their moral  upbringing or  environment  or  hormonal  development  or psychological  heritage   attach  no  importance to their  sex  organ   and are prepared to  sell it.
According  to J.C Flugel  in  his  book “The  Psycho Analytic  Study  of  a Family”, the  sexual  elements of  love  are  more  frequently  aroused  in  a woman together  with tenderness and  esteem whereas  in  a man, they  can  be isolated  from each other.Most  women  may  only  be  capable  of   having  sex only  with a  man   with whom  they  are  in love  while some  men  are   content  with  having  sex  with  a slut  just  for  the  sake  of  gratification.
Critics  of  commercial  sex  argue that  it  encourages  violence  against  women.“I  am  down  on  whores   and  shan’t  quit  ripping them  till I  do  get  buckled…”  is  a  quote from  a  letter  sent  to  the press  by    someone  claiming  to  be  Jack  the  Ripper,the  notorious White Chapel  murderer in  1888.It  has  been  suggested  that  prostitution    facilitates   murder of  sex workers.Sex  workers  experience  violence  from  clients  or  men  who  pretend  to  be  clients,vigilantes,muggers,robbers,partners,pimps  and  managers. Violence  from  clients and vigilantes and  robbers  often  takes  place  while  the victim  is at  work.At  the  street level  the  public  nature   of  the  work  exposes  them  to  aggression  from street people   and  clients.A  sex  worker   may  have  sex  in a  car,or  outdoors,in  alleyways, industrial  units,parks,derelict  buildings buildings or    go to  the clients home.
Potterat et  al(2003) state  that in  the  United  States  .  sex  workers  are  more likely  to  be   murdered than  women  of  similar  demographic  charateristics.They  concluded that  the  homicide rate  is  many  times  higher than  for  any  occupation  in  the developed  world.”
Location  of  work  is  a  critical  factor  regarding  the  risk  of  being murdered, The   risk  of  being  murdered  as  a  sex  worker  is  higher  for  street walkers.An  analysis
of  press   reports  of    84  deaths  and  disappearances of  sex workers in  the  UK between
1990 and 2004  shows  that  only one   out  of the group  was male.The  majority  were street
workers  who  were  last  seen  alive  while  working.While  others  worked  from  pubs
and  lorry  parks.Only  one  indoor  worker  was   killed  at  premises  were  other  people  were  present  at  the  time  of  the  murder.Eight  other  indoor workers were   found  dead either  in  their  own premises  or  in the   homes of  clients  who  were    subsequently  convicted.
.Indoor workers  may operate  alone, making  them  vulnerable  to  attack; where  they operate  in  a group  they  may  be  targeted  for  robbery  since  the  more  workers there are  in  one place, the  greater  the amount of  cash  likely   to  be  on the premises. Research  carried  out  by  Channel  4 in 2002  found  52 per  cent of sex  workers  experienced attacks  for  no apparent  reason.
However,some  of  the possible  reasons that  may  have triggered  the  attacks include  sex  workers  refusing  the  type  of services the client wanted ,disputes over  money  or  clients  refusing to pay,sex workers  saying time up  before the  client  could  ejaculate after  being paid or the client  being unable to  get an erection.
Clients’  problems  with ejaculation are  frequently  related to alcohol use  which in itself  has  potential  for violence.Since  much sex  work takes place at  night as  pubs  and clubs  are closing  sex  workers  will be exposed  to  the  effects of alcohol  from  their clientele.
Physical  location  facilitates  violence  against street workers  since  interaction  takes  place
In  dark,isolated places  where  attacks take place.Clients  and  others who  attack  sex workers share  common social  attitudes that  sex workers  are  worthless individuals, degraded women who  deserve punishment. It  would  be  difficult change  such  attitudes  as  long  as policies  and  public statements  about  sex  work reinforce  an atmosphere  of abhorrence aimed at shaming  and  humiliating clients.
Sex  worker deaths  by  homicide are  likely  to be  unrecorded since  the  coding system  does  not  include in its  record  of “key  occupation” those  women
who  have  other   forms  of  unemployment or  whose  involvement in sex work is concealed.
Women  who  work in  institutions providing sex-related  entertainment  such  as night clubs,escort services  or massage parlours   have   a  sexual  identity  which is defined
as  a personal service.They  are  largely  protected  from  the police,the law  and  the court.The  legal  framework  in  which these  commercial  institutions they operate does
not view  prostitutes  as  criminals  but  as  wage workers. Prostitution  law  affects  them only  when it  can  be  proved that  they  have  engaged  in  sex  for  money
Physical  coercion, abduction  and  debt bondage  deprive  women  of their  civil  and  human rights  which  are  exploited  to  turn  them  into  objects of  slave labour.Whatever physical  assets  they  may possess  are  to  be  used  to  provide pleasure  for  their clients  while  they
derive no lasting  rewards   except  maintenance  provided  by  the brothel owner who collects all  the benefits.In cases  of  socio-economic  coercion  women  must  compete with
each other  and  expose  their  assets  to  attract  clients.They  must also  invest  in  their  assets  to  maintain their  value  by  buying  clothing  and  cosmetics  and  ensure  a certain  degree of  mobility  within the hierarchy  of the sex industry.Such  mobility determined  by
the sustainability  of  their  physical  appearance  and fluctuations  in the market. Downward
mobility  from  well paid  forms  of  prostitution  to  street  soliciting  may   occur  in  the course  of   the  hooker’s  life.Upward   mobility   is  also  possible   for  hookers  who  use
their  experience  in  the different  institutions  to  acquire knowledge  about the  market
in  order  to  operate  more  independently.
The  institutionalisation  of  criminality   in prostitution  compromises the  position of  hookers  in relation  to  their  employers  and  clients  and  worsens  the  existing  relation
of patronage. The  criminalisation  of  prostitution  renders  hookers  more  vulnerable to
control  by employers  of  their  physical mobility,labour  and earnings.The  use  of the  wage
system  as     a redistributive  measure  and  a  bargaining  tool is therefore minimised.
Discrimination  against  prostitutes  is   considered  to  as one  of  a  more  generalized  trend  of  discrimination  through  sex-stereotyped  occupations  in  the  wage  labour  sector
where  women  are crowded  into  a  limited  range  of  low paid  servicing functions on  the basis of their gender. A  parallel is  drawn     between prostitution  and  other  sex stereotyped  occupations such  as  waitresses, fashion models and secretaries. Therefore, hookers
should not  be  criticised  as  the  only women opting  for work  which  in  some
ways panders to male dominance. In  a  society  with  sexual  disadvantages, the  choice
presented  to  women generally  by  way  of   wage labour or  domestic  work  is likely to  lead to the same  trap.
The  English  collective of  prostitutes stated   in  a newsletter  it  is poverty   which  should  outlawed   and  prostitution.It  is  argued that  it  is  one form  of women’s  struggle  to  get paid  for  housework-by  getting paid  for  the sexual services  all women are  expected  to  give for free.”After  all,who are prostitutes  but housewives  who go out  for  an  evening  job.”Against this  thesis it  has been stated that it  is impossible  to  equate  a housewife  with  a  hooker  on  the basis  of poverty  and wagelessness  because not  all  hookers  are poor  and  not   all poor housewives  enter  prostitution.
In  conclusion,society’s hatred  of  commercial  sex  has resulted in laws  and law   enforcement  strategies  that  prevent neither  violence  nor  exploitation  of sex workers.The
legal  framework makes  all  forms of sex work dangerous  and  proposals for  making it safe
are   rejected in order  not  to  encourage prostitution.            
  
                        